Choco, the early auto tensioner that came out in the 06 dynas have been known to fail, the newer version is stronger and works pretty good, yeah that over tensioning scenario can occur, but in most cases I've heard of the bike was ridden like it was stolen, hard revs and throttle chops being the main culprit from what I understand, causes the chain to flex and go slack over the tensioner and it can ramp up, the best fix is to drill it and put a bolt in it if that's something you are prone to doing but myself personally have never had a problem with them, not saying it don't happen but it's not as common as the internet would have you believe.
My 2006 Roadking had a standard adjustable one.