Doesn’t look right, 2015 and earlier there is a foam/rubber gasket (P/No: 11100055) between the screen and fairing.
I have a 2012 and there is definitely NO gasket between the screen and fairing on that yr
I like bbs idea. You could get a pkt of those simple reddish fibre washers. Won’t scratch and won’t compress. I think the missus got me a pkt of assorted ones from Aldi.