its a 2002 fatboy. I forget if the gauge used to drop to empty when the ignition is off. Mine is stuck on full
If you are saying that your gauge reads full with ignition off, then I would say it is the actual gauge that is at fault. Just to confirm that, disconnect all wires at gauge to see that it still reads full.
no fuel gauge here, I wait till I need reserve turned on. unless a long way between servo's.