Australias Best Pie Reviews

5/5
  • mickle
    mickle
    5 years ago
    Quoting steelo on 12 Nov 2019 09:25 AMedited: 12 Nov 2019 09:26 AM

    What would you rate that on the mickle scale?

    Fish Pie? the smell would rate a 10, the pie a 0. 
  • taztiger4
    taztiger4
    5 years ago
    Quoting steelo on 12 Nov 2019 09:25 AMedited: 12 Nov 2019 09:26 AM

    What would you rate that on the mickle scale?

    Quoting mickle on 12 Nov 2019 09:37 AM

    Fish Pie? the smell would rate a 10, the pie a 0. 

    LOL
  • keith
    keith
    5 years ago


    9/10 for the beef gravy pie in Donnybrook. 
  • mickle
    mickle
    4 years ago

    Nagambie Bakery Victoria between Seymour and Shepparton.

    Nearly didn't get a picture of this one as the Stockman would be one of my favourite pies and I was starving, anyway I thought of you lot and pulled off to the
    side of the road and grabbed a snap on the front seat of the Hilux before it was devoured.
    This bakery has had a recent change of ownership (not Asian) so will keep my eye on it.
    9/10


  • bigfella236
    bigfella236
    4 years ago
    A recent trip to Toodyay for a little run for the partner to see. We stopped of at the Toodyay bakery for a pie and coffee, i can say if your there do drop in there bloody good pies. 
  • Lozz
    Lozz
    4 years ago
    Newhaven Pie Shop on Phillip Island does a decent pie, scallop pies, steak & kidney, thai Chicken 7Plus I would say & Thorpdale Bakery on the way to/from Trafalalgar on a lovely twisty riding road. Good range & other tucker for the sweet tooth.  
  • keith
    keith
    4 years ago
    Homemade Steak Pepper pie at the Blue Wren Café Dwellingup this morning 7/10.

  • imoo6170
    imoo6170
    4 years ago
    For anyone in the Sydney region I recommend Luddenham Pieshop, shop 1, Northern Road, Luddenham 2745.
    All the Pies are great (love the potato tomato and cheese pie) as well as the Pasties and Sausage rolls. Their family pies are a favourite of my wife (and she is not a big pie fan). Be aware that they only take cash. This is their facebook page https://www.facebook.com/luddenhampieshop

    Btw they regularly sell out of the family pies (even though they bake them several times a day) 
  • beaglebasher
    beaglebasher
    4 years ago
    what a post !  One of the best  I have read.  
    Where is old rodders now?
  • gidgi
    gidgi
    4 years ago
    whoa! what an epic tale, bet it took longer to write this post than to eat "Said  pie" 
  • Slowen down
    Slowen down
    4 years ago
    No knife n fork
    If the temp is right you should be able to eat a pie in 4 bites.
    If the dog's eye is too hot the dead horse should cool it down enough.
  • brucefxdl
    brucefxdl
    4 years ago
    Quoting Slowen down on 11 Jun 2020 05:18 AM

    No knife n fork

    If the temp is right you should be able to eat a pie in 4 bites.
    If the dog's eye is too hot the dead horse should cool it down enough.

    remind me not to leave a pie resting near you.....lol.
  • Slowen down
    Slowen down
    4 years ago
    Slowen down on the riding but not on the tooth.
    Love a good dogs eye n dead horse (or 2 if shes not watching).
    Use to like the Fredos Pies up this way but the quality dropped off a bit when the changed shops.
  • keith
    keith
    4 years ago
    Bindoon Bakehaus, never disappoints.

  • Slowen down
    Slowen down
    4 years ago
    I'm hungry
  • keith
    keith
    1 year ago
    Quoting bigfella236 on 01 Dec 2019 09:19 AM

    A recent trip to Toodyay for a little run for the partner to see. We stopped of at the Toodyay bakery for a pie and coffee, i can say if your there do drop in there bloody good pies. 

    Stopped off in Toodyay today, no doubt good pies, and very busy. Another old thread re-booted.
5/5