Online: Hilly

Australias Best Pie Reviews

4/5
  • fatbat
    fatbat
    5 years ago
    Quoting mickle on 23 Mar 2019 06:14 AM

    Penola SA just over the border from Victoria, Windara Bakery, very good pie 8/10 but not sure what flavour it was, it defiantly wasn't the Mushroom I asked for.


    Quoting Krash Kinkade on 23 Mar 2019 07:49 PM

    mickle, just noticed the iced coffee. what's the story behind South Aussies love of iced coffee?

    Calling mick a souf Australian will not go down well haha 
  • mickle
    mickle
    5 years ago
    Beechworth Bakery at Bright after a night in the Alpine Hotel partying.

    Mushroom, maybe 7 or 8 this one, few mushrooms about, nice gravy and very fresh, sauce out of a bottle.


  • rkr
    rkr
    5 years ago
    The Bodalla Dairy Shed has a beef brisket pie that is delicious. Also the best vanilla thickshake I have had.  
  • bloodog
    bloodog
    5 years ago
    Quoting mickle on 14 Apr 2019 01:36 AM

    Beechworth Bakery at Bright after a night in the Alpine Hotel partying.

    Mushroom, maybe 7 or 8 this one, few mushrooms about, nice gravy and very fresh, sauce out of a bottle.


    Awesome photo 
  • mickle
    mickle
    5 years ago
    Reviews need pictures fellas for us at home to judge, I can tell a good pie just by looking at it.
  • keith
    keith
    5 years ago
    Quoting mickle on 22 Apr 2019 10:01 PM

    Reviews need pictures fellas for us at home to judge, I can tell a good pie just by looking at it.

    I second that motion Mickle !
  • mickle
    mickle
    5 years ago
    Looks tasty but somewhat deflated.
  • beaglebasher
    beaglebasher
    5 years ago
    Brilliant description of the age old culinary experience of eating a pie rodders.
    Most impressed indeed!
  • mickle
    mickle
    5 years ago
    I tell ya next I go to Noojee it will be for the pub not a deflated Wine and Beef pie, I am guessing that's what it was as
    you sound pissed, must have been a strong one. I did notice you had used your fingers to place a morsel of meet on the top
    of the pie causing the deflation, I would have used a fork. 
  • brucefxdl
    brucefxdl
    5 years ago
    Quoting beaglebasher on 25 Apr 2019 09:07 AM

    Brilliant description of the age old culinary experience of eating a pie rodders.

    Most impressed indeed!

    yes , agree bb.
  • dyna matt
    dyna matt
    5 years ago
    Quoting mickle on 10 Feb 2019 10:10 PM

    Ok I will kick it off with a great Pie at Stone Hut SA, maybe not the best but 7/10 I would say.

    Kiwi eating a Mushroom pie I think it was.


    If you get back to stone hut mickle (unsure where you are), try the crocodile and lemon myrtle pie. Im only half hour away and its always a good stop off, especially when its cold
    Recently tried the pepper steak at the little shop in coffin bay, rated it as one of my favourites in the last 12 months or so, if not longer.
  • Sprinter64
    Sprinter64
    5 years ago
    My all time fav pie is from Villis in Geelong, they sell them all over Vic, awesome pie that never fails, get em at Kardinia park during the footy, fkn ace.
    Not aussie but I had to go to NZ twice this week for work and there's a pop up shop in Wellington airport with an excellent steak number.
  • mickle
    mickle
    5 years ago
    Reviewed this one before, Stone Hut Bakery SA, this is a chicken and mushroom that would have been very nice if hot. 8 out 10


    Pepper Steak, I didn't try it but Halzie said it was good.


  • wello
    wello
    5 years ago
    fatso,s ??
  • liberator
    liberator
    5 years ago
    And their Vanilla Slices's are to die for,
  • mickle
    mickle
    5 years ago
    Beechworth bakery in Echuca Vic, no picture of the Mushroom pie because it was shit, I left it sitting on the plate and walked across the road to the
    Moama Bakery for a toasted sanga.


  • Krash Kinkade
    Krash Kinkade
    5 years ago
    mickle now I'll have to ride to Stone Hut SA that pie looks good!! no good to hear about Beechworth Bakery. as I have posted before, the best pies I've had are at Haydens Pies Ulladulla, someone told me he learnt his trade in Ireland, but I don't know, but do know they are good pies!! no pic's but will try get some next time
  • Baloffski
    Baloffski
    5 years ago
    Fucken Echuca Beechworth Fucken Bakery..
    Know not pie topic, for that apologies.
    Had a toasted sanga, ham cheese and tomato, was so fucken sick, from food poisoning. Obviously the ham had been sitting on that sanga for years, and a mug like me was crook all day. 
    Beware... they have their tucker sitting until some cunts come and order.
    And yes, have had pie from same Beechworth and it was shite, too.

    Last week had pie at Kyneton bakery, which is an award winning seafood satay, didn't turn me on, but was a 6 from 10, utilising the 'Mickle ' scale.
  • Far Canal
    Far Canal
    5 years ago


  • steelo
    steelo
    5 years ago
    What would you rate that on the mickle scale?
4/5