thats actually a tuff n .   the FX has traces of classic HD but the Rod is the bravest step HD took .
both are extinct
be aware that you are actually a genuine classic bike collector according to AMCA , any billet has to go tho.

as they sit Id go Vrod 

ralphs ideas the best.  1 of each of the bet hd's made.  

Springer wins 

FXSTSSE2 Springer all the way.

HOWEVER I will admit to blatant bias...( LOVE my own FXSTSSE2 in the same "color" sorry "colour" ! ) 

Two of my old riding mates , both Vietnam Vets in their mid 70's have the original 2002/3 Anodised V-Rods , and yes they LOVE them haha..