poll : Yay or Nay?

1/2
  • mrjessehlee
    mrjessehlee
    6 years ago
    Hi guys, I'm in the process of building a new look for my softail. 
    Just mocked up the tank and the seat and been getting some conflict in opinion (some rather strong) on how shit the bike now looks. 
    Some will say "do what YOU want" and I get it. but at the same time I want to build something that's generally considered beautiful too. So before I put more of my heart, soul and hard earned $ into my project I'd like to know what the general consensus form us "Harley guys" would be on the LOOKS of this current status of the bike. So BESIDES THE PRACTICALITY side of things, what do you guys think of it? You guys remember the "Cool Wall" from Top Gear? just think of this poll like that, so yay or nay? Thanks in advance. (masking tape is only there to protect the paint finish. the tank is of 2016 fourty eight in black.)


  • paulybronco
    paulybronco
    6 years ago
    Fuck me here we go again! Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, why oh why would you care what others think of your bike. Break out of your "must be liked by others" mode and build it yourself for yourself
  • Baloffski
    Baloffski
    6 years ago
    HH on the money again, but get rid of those bloody bicycles, they have no motor and look like hard work .
    Go with heart, and head a little.
  • Kingchops
    Kingchops
    6 years ago
    Yes for me, I think it looks good.  The classic Sporty tank has a great look to it regardless of what bike you put it on.  Aligning it high on the backbone is also a great look.  And those sprung seats only look good on Softail frames.  On the side of practicality, I would have used a 3.3gal Sporty tank. But I guess if the ultimate look is what you're after the 48 tank looks better.
    Also, have to agree with others, don't ask for opinions on style, do what you think looks best.  You're the one that's going to have to ride it. 
  • tussuck
    tussuck
    6 years ago
    Nay.....  Looks like a tweaked Rocker.
  • Paz141
    Paz141
    6 years ago
    Thats a no from me
  • bloodog
    bloodog
    6 years ago
    I HATE FORK SOCKS 
    its a bit hard to judge with no back muddy and the tape on the tank 
    Im an overweight Thrashed out red head and have to work with what I have, so same as the rest, make the bike to what floats your boat bro
  • Big Steve
    Big Steve
    6 years ago
    First pic yes, second no. Not a fan of spring solo seats (especially on bikes with suspension)
  • WideglidingNZ
    WideglidingNZ
    6 years ago
    I don't like the tank or the seat, just my opinion
  • mrjessehlee
    mrjessehlee
    6 years ago
    wow thanks for all the replies. Very interesting! 
  • Humbug
    Humbug
    6 years ago
    Do what makes you happy. After all its your money your ride.
  • Soapbox2627
    Soapbox2627
    6 years ago
    I think your missus looks like shit and you should dump her
    I prefer a smooth skin with nice legs and that just funnel to a nice box gap, B tits and brunette

    Sorry mate, no disrespect to you or your wife/partner/girlfriend, you build your family/bike your way as that is your taste, ya canny please everyone (nor should you need to try)
  • B0GN
    B0GN
    6 years ago
    What’s the back wheel covering gonna look like? 
    It’s not bad as you’ve got it but it needs a bit of arse end balance. 
  • kevinc
    kevinc
    6 years ago
    I prefer the bog standard bike.
    The other one looks cobbled together by a drunken dwarf.
  • B0GN
    B0GN
    6 years ago
    Well, for what it’s worth, I like it. Personally, I have a thing for low slung bars, particularly on a bike of this shape. But do what make you happy :-)
  • TC883
    TC883
    6 years ago
    Yay from me mate. Like where you are going with it.
  • DJP_120ci
    DJP_120ci
    6 years ago
    There is potential there for sure, bars need to be rolled foreword for a start. And there is way to much backbone exposed between the tank and seat. 
    In saying that though, who gives a rats what I think? Build it how you like it, ride and enjoy.
  • Methuselah
    Methuselah
    6 years ago
    I like it, except the pipes. They need to be black?
  • softfat
    softfat
    6 years ago
    My opinion, and everyone has one, is the tank looks too small in comparison to the engine. Big engine under a little short tank. Tank doesn't look part of the bike, and looks as though it's just sitting there. If the tank traveled further down the spine of the bike, it may look better. So I say nay.
    Soft...
  • Mr.Mow
    Mr.Mow
    6 years ago
    Hmm, personally it looks unbalanced at the rear, lot of visual weight in the front with little at the back.
    I do bike illustration and the big thing I’ve learned about drawing old choppers and vintage bikes is it’s the openness and space on them that made them look as cool as the did.. the motors were a lot less bulky, no wiring, more open frames etc.

    Modern motors and frames are bulky as fck, hard to do..

    Maybe try a very short sissy bar on the back, maybe raise the guard a little and extend it back, possibly even one with a duck tail.. maybe mount a tailight on top, just small things to add a little weight to the ass end.. maybe some high up shotgun pipes, maybe visually bring things up a bit.

    End of the day it’s gotta be vaguely street legal too!
1/2