Bought my bike new in Feb 2008.
So the ORIGINAL battery has just turned 9, and still seems fine.
Gobsmacked! to be blunt.
Do you sing it a lullaby to sleep every night?? The best I had (on a Jap bike) was eight years and still going strong ... but it was hooked up to a trickle charger every night.
I still use the charger on the HD -- last winter, she was struggling to turn over on the -3--5 degree mornings but using the trickle charger cured that.
2.5 yrs with my street glide
My 09 rocker has the original battery and going strong...... the bike did sit unused for some years but...
Given the size of the batteris in bikes you want to use a low amp device.
Most are 0.8 to 1.2amp for bike batteries. Yes a larger one will charge but a slow, low rate of charge over a period of time is much gentler on the batterys internals
Im convinced the faulty new one I bought was a bit dodgy from the beginnning as I have two tenders (Optimate & CTek) and noticed with the Optimate that if I plugged it in when I got back from a ride the battery would not accept charge until the residual / static voltage dropped below 13v. The Optimate would giove a Red (sulfated) indication but I thought maybe it was just the battery settling in.....then when it refused to start I knew I was right and it was load tested after a 1 hour charge to 160cca....good for a whipper snipper but not a harley
In regards to your 9yr old battery, put the multimeter on it or the tender lead and observe what the voltage drops to when starting the bike.
If it drops below 10.5v then it may be showing signs of wear but hey, 9 years & still going is excellent
last bit of advice, if you do get a new one, put it on the tender for at least 48hrs before installing in the bike so it gets a fulll charge and the absorption process into the plates goes through a few cycles