Fatal chase cop Timothy Hughes accused of lying to inquest

  • twincam88b
    twincam88b
    15 years ago

    A POLICE officer who fatally chased a motorcyclist at high-speed through a busy shopping precinct has been accused of lying to a coronial inquest into the death.

    The inquest, into the 2005 death of Adam Keneth McNamara, today heard Senior Constable Timothy Hughes claim he had not seen the fatal motorcycle crash.

    Transcripts that were read to the court of an interview during a commissioner's inquiry, however, indicate that he did.

    In the transcripts Hughes describes the back tyre of the motorcycle hitting the median strip on Elizabeth Way, near the Elizabeth Shopping Centre and sending McNamara spinning off his bike.

    Deputy State Coroner Anthony Schapel questioned how Hughes could have described the accident so accurately but now tell him that he did not see it.

    "Isn't that (the description he gave) a lot to presume from the observation of a stationary human being and a motorbike?" Mr Schapel said.

    "The previous interviews show that you have seen it (the accident)."

    "Are you trying to hide the fact that you were close enough behind the motorcycle to see the crash?"

    Hughes, 36, who now lives in Western Australia, today said he had terminated the chase moments before the crash.

    In a legal first, Hughes was found guilty of dangerous driving in October last year over the chase.

    He was given a six-month licence disqualification and $300 fine.

    Hughes, told the inquest his decision to chase unlicensed motorcyclist Mr McNamara at 80km/h on the wrong side of the road through a built up area with "plenty"of pedestrians was not unreasonable.

    He said the chase was terminated 27 seconds after it started because he realised McNamara was not going to pull over.

    The inquest is continuing.

    http://www.news.com.au/adelaidenow/story/0,22606,25909577-5006301,00.html

    Why am I not surprised

  • FLSTC
    FLSTC
    15 years ago
    ok ... well it looks like he may have lied to save his arse , but people have got to be responsible for their own stupid actions including failing to pull over.
  • Andyroo
    Andyroo
    15 years ago
    = Hughes, told the inquest his decision to chase unlicensed motorcyclist Mr McNamara at 80km/h on the wrong side of the road through a built up area with "plenty"of pedestrians was not unreasonable.


    Why the hell is this dumbass even a cop? I would very much like to hear his ideas of what is unreasonable.
  • Soapbox2627
    Soapbox2627
    15 years ago
    I agree with Alby, but if the thief has an accident evading police, I don't think compensation should be able to be sought.
  • Soapbox2627
    Soapbox2627
    15 years ago
    7 news tonight, same thing, chase called off 200m before the accident.